
Dissident Philosophy Forum welcome to the new culture |
|
| |
| Author | Message |
|---|
Liche

 | Subject: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Sep 29, 2009 3:00 am | |
| Do thoughts have mass? (Once again, my interests in Noetic science was sparked by Dan Brown)
This would mean, if there were enought thoughts in one group, they would have gravity, gravity affecting the physical world. This would also mean we could affect the physical world with our mind, this theory also coincides with the possibility of humans having higher power over their mind and the physical world, and would probably be able to tap into this power spiritually, or via arcane rituals.
This would mean, that virtually anything is possible. |
|  | | Natalia

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Sep 29, 2009 3:22 am | |
| In my view, thoughts do not have mass. (How would you put a mind onto a scale?) |
|  | | Liche

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Sep 29, 2009 10:12 pm | |
| Id supposed youd have to make a scale for measuring them, and it wouldnt be measured in sense of length weight or depth, but more in potency. Or maybe once we master our minds, we gain new kinds of thought power, which would have weight.
Im not saying they do, I just think its an intersting concepty, in fact Im pretty sure they dont, considering your brain dosent get larger the more you think. |
|  | | Natalia

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Wed Sep 30, 2009 12:47 am | |
| | Liche wrote: | | Id supposed youd have to make a scale for measuring them, and it wouldnt be measured in sense of length weight or depth, but more in potency. |
This sounds just right.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potential_energy
| Quote: | | This would mean, that virtually anything is possible. |
Yep. Unknown max potential. |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Fri Oct 02, 2009 9:48 am | |
| One of the properties of mass is weight in a gravity field. That is quite measurable. What might be a problem is matching any particular thought to any particular change in weight. The quantity of thought in any particular mind at any particular moment is probably difficult to determine. Perhaps an electroencephalograph could manage some sort of technique to indicate mental activity and match it with a weight change but the change, if any, would probably be so minuscule as to be impossible to differentiate from some other physiological activity such as a fart or a burp. I've been farting and burping at intervals throughout my life and discovered no personal power over the universe as a consequence. |
|  | | Quinn

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Nov 10, 2009 6:52 pm | |
| | Sand wrote: | | One of the properties of mass is weight in a gravity field. That is quite measurable. What might be a problem is matching any particular thought to any particular change in weight. The quantity of thought in any particular mind at any particular moment is probably difficult to determine. Perhaps an electroencephalograph could manage some sort of technique to indicate mental activity and match it with a weight change but the change, if any, would probably be so minuscule as to be impossible to differentiate from some other physiological activity such as a fart or a burp. I've been farting and burping at intervals throughout my life and discovered no personal power over the universe as a consequence. |
This is complete sci-fi -- psy-fi!
How much does the mind weight?
Answer me this too:
In centimeters, how wide is the field-of-vision? |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Nov 10, 2009 7:00 pm | |
| | Quinn wrote: | | Sand wrote: | | One of the properties of mass is weight in a gravity field. That is quite measurable. What might be a problem is matching any particular thought to any particular change in weight. The quantity of thought in any particular mind at any particular moment is probably difficult to determine. Perhaps an electroencephalograph could manage some sort of technique to indicate mental activity and match it with a weight change but the change, if any, would probably be so minuscule as to be impossible to differentiate from some other physiological activity such as a fart or a burp. I've been farting and burping at intervals throughout my life and discovered no personal power over the universe as a consequence. |
This is complete sci-fi -- psy-fi!
How much does the mind weight?
Answer me this too:
In centimeters, how wide is the field-of-vision? |
There is no doubt that kinetic energy does increase the weight of a mechanism extremely slightly so you would have to discover the weight of a nervous system that is totally quiescent against one that is dynamic. It's not impossible, merely difficult. A field of vision is measured in angles, not centimeters and that is done regularly with no problems at all. |
|  | | Quinn

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Nov 10, 2009 9:47 pm | |
| | Sand wrote: | | Quinn wrote: | | Sand wrote: | | One of the properties of mass is weight in a gravity field. That is quite measurable. What might be a problem is matching any particular thought to any particular change in weight. The quantity of thought in any particular mind at any particular moment is probably difficult to determine. Perhaps an electroencephalograph could manage some sort of technique to indicate mental activity and match it with a weight change but the change, if any, would probably be so minuscule as to be impossible to differentiate from some other physiological activity such as a fart or a burp. I've been farting and burping at intervals throughout my life and discovered no personal power over the universe as a consequence. |
This is complete sci-fi -- psy-fi!
How much does the mind weight?
Answer me this too:
In centimeters, how wide is the field-of-vision? |
There is no doubt that kinetic energy does increase the weight of a mechanism extremely slightly |
How does Kinetic Energy increase the Weight of a Machine?
- kinetic energy:

- machine:
"a mechanical device that changes the direction or magnitude of a force"
- weight:
F = m·a Weight (w) w = m·g The machine can not be seperated from the direction and magnitude of the force, it has to be impossibly factored in as a part of the whole that is acting on the part, instantaneously changing it again and ruining the calculation; okay; this is dialectical reason. You mean the exchange between Energy and Matter in an Entropic Universe? Everything is getting heavier.
| Quote: | | so you would have to discover the weight of a nervous system that is totally quiescent against one that is dynamic. It's not impossible, merely difficult. |
A change in the Weight of a Nervous System does not say anything about the weight of the mind. Weight is in the mind, trying to weigh the mind is like trying to fill jars with cup-boards.
| Quote: | | A field of vision is measured in angles, not centimeters and that is done regularly with no problems at all. |
There is an angle and perspective, and I am always the view-point. I see what you mean, it's about 180°. Many animals see all around them. This is the standard "receding railroad tracks" phenomenon; in my perspective things at a distance merge into a point of zero at an infinite distance; from my end, my visual perspective must be infinity wide. The distance between the right and the left; by this analogy, mind would have a weight of infinity; the whole weight of the universe. The circularity of things all around us in nature gives me the impression that we see the universe turned inside-out like a sock a total 360°.
the view-point is infinity wide
Last edited by Quinn on Tue Nov 10, 2009 10:16 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Nov 10, 2009 10:00 pm | |
| a point of zero anywhere in infinity:
there are no dumb questions, are there? supposed those points were inhabited? |
|  | | Quinn

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Nov 10, 2009 10:15 pm | |
| | lavender orchid wrote: | a point of zero anywhere in infinity:
there are no dumb questions, are there? supposed those points were inhabited? |
Not just once, each space of infinity can again be inhabited by infinity spaces because not only each space of a level of infinity, but the space of each subsequent space, and spaces' space, and so on; closer to home: such as the mind may have mind-organs: demi-minds and slave-minds that do psychic machine work, the mind may be part of, or at the end of all sorts of psychic-cellular and organal dark-matter machinery that connects the mind to the visible matter of the biological-physical body. Whole eons of evolution have built intricate invisible super-spacial complexes that chain together, beating and pumping in invisible dimensions. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Tue Nov 10, 2009 10:46 pm | |
| | Quinn wrote: | | lavender orchid wrote: | a point of zero anywhere in infinity:
there are no dumb questions, are there? supposed those points were inhabited? |
Not just once, each space of infinity can again be inhabited by infinity spaces because not only each space of a level of infinity, but the space of each subsequent space, and spaces' space, and so on; closer to home: such as the mind may have mind-organs: demi-minds and slave-minds that do psychic machine work, the mind may be part of, or at the end of all sorts of psychic-cellular and organal dark-matter machinery that connects the mind to the visible matter of the biological-physical body. Whole eons of evolution have built intricate invisible super-spacial complexes that chain together, beating and pumping in invisible dimensions. |
aha. so what, eh? |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Wed Nov 11, 2009 1:31 am | |
| What may be is not necessarily what is. |
|  | | rhinosaur

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Wed Nov 18, 2009 6:17 pm | |
| Thoughts don't need mass to affect the external world. It's simply information-transference. In this day and age, we cannot talk sensibly about the world and about progress unless we talk in terms of information-flow. That is to say, all reality is energy in flux (flowing), and the means by which we interact within the flow is information-transference. For example, you smell lavender and the every cell in your body receives neurotransmitters in the proper receptors. Your body receives the information, is changed by the information, and radiates information that changes others. You experience a relaxing effect as a result. What it is is a dance of information, between transmitters and receptors. Ever heard of Masaru Emoto's work on the effects of thought on water? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masaru_Emoto |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Wed Nov 18, 2009 6:23 pm | |
| |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Wed Nov 18, 2009 7:13 pm | |
| rather than asking whether thoughts do have mass, i would give preference to recognizing that thoughts influence everything, and they travel fast! TRUTH:  fwiw: radically anarchist thought .... insisting on doing my own brainwashing? |
|  | | The Valkyrier

Comments: What about the sublimity of dadaism?
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 11:59 am | |
| Thoughts are electrochemical signals between neurons, and neurons are cells, so indirectly you could claim that thoughts have mass. The problem is that the you couldn't single out the thoughts because they are the effect of neurons. Hence there is no way of measuring the weight of a thought.
It is a somewhat grey area, but most would draw the line at the neuron and not include the thought as mass. A thought is a chemical process, and just as people wouldn't say "a nuclear explosion weights... or a car crash weights" it's somewhat misguiding to talk about weight of thoughts. Instead of the physical dimensions and how we measure them, in terms of density, length, height, weight etc we have other ways of measuring the effects of physical phenomenon.
Everyone can imagine a situation where gravity effects our brains, for example in heavy gravity or in zero gravity, where in both cases a human body would implode/explode. This would of course effect our thoughts, since it's hard to think about something without a brain.
To get to the point about Dan Browns psychic power theory, the most extensive research done on any supernatural phenomenon is regarding telekenisis and mind reading. So far no one has been able to present any actual evidence that such a thing exists, and this is most certainly not due to lack of funding. Organizations all the way from the scientologist community to NASA have supported pointless research in this field.
A newly released movie about such a project is "The Men Who Stare at Goats" _________________ Self-quotes: Great minds think alike. Greater minds think for themselves.
Relativism wont save you from the wrath of logic.
Knowledge is a lifestyle.
|
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 12:18 pm | |
| thoughts have mass appeal, obviously. with grave effects to what is called the psyche: depression.
mind reading and anything tele... are so normal, that it beats the common awareness of how it functions naturally.
ai? if you can't turn it off, turn away.
imho, naturally. |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 12:41 pm | |
| As long as we're getting into puns, how about light verse. Has it got less mass than heavy verse? Then, of course we have to consider subverse, converse, perverse, reverse, and universe. Universe, it seems likely, has a respectable mass. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 12:51 pm | |
| less mass, more energy. how is this measured, huh?  power comes out of a plug. usually. |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 1:07 pm | |
| | lavender orchid wrote: | less mass, more energy. how is this measured, huh? 
power comes out of a plug. usually. |
Knowledge is power and there are various plugs. Some come out of tobacco pipes, some keep the water in the bathtub, some run in horse races, and some advertise products on the radio. An electric plug, of course, could be a battery powered robot horse. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 1:15 pm | |
| which answers the mass appeal question, to certain extents. another one would be asking for the difference between lights and luminaries, perhaps.
does charm have a weight, like mass? |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 1:20 pm | |
| | lavender orchid wrote: | which answers the mass appeal question, to certain extents. another one would be asking for the difference between lights and luminaries, perhaps.
does charm have a weight, like mass? |
Rubens thought so. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 1:26 pm | |
| baroque didn't last though. sibelius took on (2?) another heavyness. |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 2:13 pm | |
| Although Catholics have mass, it seems to me to be rather thoughtless routine ceremony so there's a problem. |
|  | | Quinn

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 6:08 pm | |
| | The Valkyrier wrote: | Thoughts are electrochemical signals between neurons, and neurons are cells, so indirectly you could claim that thoughts have mass. The problem is that the you couldn't single out the thoughts because they are the effect of neurons. Hence there is no way of measuring the weight of a thought.
It is a somewhat grey area, but most would draw the line at the neuron and not include the thought as mass. A thought is a chemical process, and just as people wouldn't say "a nuclear explosion weights... or a car crash weights" it's somewhat misguiding to talk about weight of thoughts. Instead of the physical dimensions and how we measure them, in terms of density, length, height, weight etc we have other ways of measuring the effects of physical phenomenon. |
Sir! What is the field of vision made of? (For example, a cake is made of flour and eggs; or quartz is made of silicon and oxygen.) You are making wild assumptions; brain and mind are connected, okay; but, by saying: 'My grandmother weighs eight stone', that doesn't say anything about the mass of her house-robe.
| Sand wrote: | | Knowledge is power and there are various plugs. Some come out of tobacco pipes, some keep the water in the bathtub, some run in horse races, and some advertise products on the radio. An electric plug, of course, could be a battery powered robot horse. |
Interesting metaphor... |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Sat Nov 21, 2009 6:31 pm | |
| | Sand wrote: | | Although Catholics have mass, it seems to me to be rather thoughtless routine ceremony so there's a problem. |
sober analysis of ceremoniously practiced pseudo-sancticity would identify the problem as tiresome, and medicine rather cumbersome, lest thought gets re-animated. |
|  | | Guest Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 3:56 am | |
| | Liche wrote: | Do thoughts have mass? (Once again, my interests in Noetic science was sparked by Dan Brown)
This would mean, if there were enought thoughts in one group, they would have gravity, gravity affecting the physical world. This would also mean we could affect the physical world with our mind, this theory also coincides with the possibility of humans having higher power over their mind and the physical world, and would probably be able to tap into this power spiritually, or via arcane rituals.
This would mean, that virtually anything is possible. | ll sorts of paradoxes arise from such etheral qualities likes thoughts and the matter which makes it happen.
Truth be told, it seems that thoughts are more like a quantum information within the spacetime realm itself. Obviously its bound within the specific corporeal white and gray matter we call our brains, but thoughts themselves are conceptual at best.
As we become aware (its actually little quantum actions interpreting their electromagnetic energy) and from this large bundle of mass (each brain consists of around 10^26 particles in average), somehow awareness enters our body (but that can be a seperate discussion).
It's similar as to asking whether the world i look at is physical? It isn't actually. It is a representation from that single particle of photon (and through complex chemical changes and electrolyte conductivity) reaches the brain, and recreates that information. So our experiences cannot be physical. Is a thought an experience, i will let you decide that, because if it is, then it is not physical at all. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:06 am | |
| were all these theories discovered by one person at a time pushing an idea forward, or was there always a dialog, like inner "reasoning" and conversations with other people.
i am asking the question specifically with respect to test and exam situations. |
|  | | Guest Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:10 am | |
| | lavender orchid wrote: | were all these theories discovered by one person at a time pushing an idea forward, or was there always a dialog, like inner "reasoning" and conversations with other people.
i am asking the question specifically with respect to test and exam situations. |
was this directed at me? |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:25 am | |
| ^if you please...  with a welcoming hi! |
|  | | Guest Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:44 am | |
| The mind-body probem certainly persists even today. Certain scientists will not entertain a though which is non-physical, whilst others say ''yeh, there's a physical mechanism.... but... it's not really a physical thing.''
As i concluded above, if our experiences (those personal inner feelings and emotions) cannot be weighed as you would expect with using kg for mass, then thoughts are purely manifested within an imaginary world (a world we all share and experience).
Parts of me would like to see a totally solpsistic idea (since the world is certainly ''recreated in here'' from observations made ''out there'') then in this experience, there is a side to the world which is not fundamentally physically, so thoughts may be a little bit of both - caused by physical interactions, but experience of those actions are reinterpreted ethereally. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:51 am | |
| was that your answer to my question?
what causes fear? a physical threat? would that not be preceded by thought patterns impacting on someone else's organism, but thus strengthening one's own? is mass then still relevant?
Mind that matter is relevent, but that the matter of the mind is not. |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 6:13 am | |
| I don't know what universe you people live in but my thoughts have been affecting my physical world all my life. I couldn't get a cup of coffee without thinking about it first. |
|  | | Quinn

 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 3:52 pm | |
| | Mr. Scientist wrote: | | it seems that thoughts are more like a quantum information within the spacetime realm itself. Obviously its bound within the specific corporeal white and gray matter we call our brains, |
Why do you say this? The mind could be a very great distance from the brain; even at another time or Universe. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:07 pm | |
| | Quinn wrote: | | Mr. Scientist wrote: | | it seems that thoughts are more like a quantum information within the spacetime realm itself. Obviously its bound within the specific corporeal white and gray matter we call our brains, |
Why do you say this? The mind could be a very great distance from the brain; even at another time or Universe. |
indeed, that's the impression one usually gets from Quinn's posts!  |
|  | | Sand

Comments: in phonetics
if any
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:08 pm | |
| | Quinn wrote: | | Mr. Scientist wrote: | | it seems that thoughts are more like a quantum information within the spacetime realm itself. Obviously its bound within the specific corporeal white and gray matter we call our brains, |
Why do you say this? The mind could be a very great distance from the brain; even at another time or Universe. |
Which means you feel it is reasonable to assume you are out of your mind. I agree. Your statements indicate that. |
|  | | Guest Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:37 pm | |
| | Quinn wrote: | | Mr. Scientist wrote: | | it seems that thoughts are more like a quantum information within the spacetime realm itself. Obviously its bound within the specific corporeal white and gray matter we call our brains, |
Why do you say this? The mind could be a very great distance from the brain; even at another time or Universe. |
I say this because I view the world from ''in here'' - not ''out there''. |
|  | | Guest Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:38 pm | |
| But am aware of information entering my nervous system. |
|  | | Guest Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 4:41 pm | |
| | lavender orchid wrote: | was that your answer to my question?
what causes fear? a physical threat? would that not be preceded by thought patterns impacting on someone else's organism, but thus strengthening one's own? is mass then still relevant?
. | Mind that matter is relevent, but that the matter of the mind is not. |
|  | | Gast Guest
 | Subject: Re: Do thoughts have mass? Mon Nov 23, 2009 5:06 pm | |
| | Mr. Scientist wrote: | | lavender orchid wrote: | was that your answer to my question?
what causes fear? a physical threat? would that not be preceded by thought patterns impacting on someone else's organism, but thus strengthening one's own? is mass then still relevant?
. | Mind that matter is relevent, but that the matter of the mind is not. |
with your kind permission, i mind what should be. |
|  | | |
Similar topics |  |
|
| | Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |
|